Much has been written in praise of Gary Oldman’s brilliant
portrayal of Winston Churchill in
Darkest Hour( which btw is not that great a film), for which he won the Oscar for the best actor.
The entire film is set in the month of May 1940, ie the first month of
his prime minister ship, and takes the
artistic liberty (a much abused term) of adding fictional elements such as
Winston Churchill travelling by the underground metro train near the film’s end
to gather the public’s general opinion on whether to enter into negotiations
with Herr Hitler or to fight on. Or having his personal secretary Elizabeth Layton
coming into the ‘war room’ to explain her the precarious situation in Dunkirk. Ridiculous,
considering that,
1. The access to the ‘war room’ cannot be given so easily ,
least of all to secretarial staff
2. Layton was his
secretary since mid 1941 whereas the film is set in May 1940.
Sir Winston Leonard Spencer Churchill (1874 - 1965) is
venerated for his leadership of the United Kingdom during the Second World War
and is considered one of the greatest
wartime leaders of the century. In
addition to being an orator, he was also a historian, a writer and an artist.
He is the only British Prime Minister to have received the Nobel Prize in
Literature (in 1953), and was the first person to be made an Honorary Citizen
of the United States. He’s been voted as the greatest Briton of all time, ahead
of Shakespeare, Newton and Darwin.
The film should be acknowledged for not shying away from
portraying him as an unpleasant , haughty, decadent man who wont abandon his
luxurious ways of cigar and champagne even in the trying days of war,his views
on India are mentioned by Edward in a passing reference, who was really wanted
by nobody, but was invited by Edward to be the PM only because he was the only
one agreeable by the opposition Labour Party .
But there are so many more unpleasant things that Hollywood
will never show about Churchill.
Alongwith Mohandas Gandhi and Nelson Mandela, he remains one of the most
whitewashed figures in world history.
Even in those imperial times, Winston Churchill was the
extreme at the end of the imperial spectrum. PM Stanley Baldwin was warned
against having him in the cabinet for his views. Even his doctor Lord Moran,
said of his views on other races: "Winston thinks only of the colour of their
skin."
According to William Manchester, "The Caged Lion",
His father, Lord Randolph Churchill, briefly Britain's Chancellor of the
Exchequer, "actually loathed Winston", wrote Manchester. His mother,
a beautiful American named Jennie Jerome, "devoted most of her time to
sexual intrigue, slipping between the sheets with handsome, powerful men in
Britain, in the United States, and on the Continent.(one of her lovers was the Her husband was in no position to object. He
was an incurable syphilitic."Not a recipe for a great childhood.
Whatever the Nazis did, British did much worse for their
colonies in Asia and Africa, and as victors in the two world wars,
found enough opportunities to do away with the evidences of their genocides and
wrongdoings. Everyone remembers the holocaust, but the millions of victims of
famines caused due to British policies of using land to grow cash crops instead
of foodcrops in two centuries are hardly acknowledged.
Benjamin Disraeli, former British PM, called India "the
brightest jewel in the crown," acknowledging India's valuable resources
that Europe exploited like spices, mineral ores, textiles, the huge pool of
cheap labour and the large market for British goods. As its largest colonial
territory, India was the most important of all the overseas possessions of the
British Empire. Britain held on to India for as long as it could, relinquishing
it only when it was thoroughly weakened by the second world war, accelerating
its departure post the naval uprising of 1946.
"Power will go into the hands of rascals, rogues, and
freebooters. Not a bottle of water or loaf of bread shall escape taxation; only
the air will be free and the blood of these hungry millions will be on the head
of Attlee." This Churchill quote is cited so often
by various people discussing the evil of corruption in India. But this doesn’t
mean Churchill was sympathetic or concerned about India or Indians ( as his views about
them can be summed in these two sentences of his:- “I hate Indians. They are a
beastly people with a beastly religion that breed like rats”, or those about Mohandas Gandhi – “He ought to be lain bound
hand and foot at the gates of Delhi, and then trampled on by an enormous
elephant with the new Viceroy seated on its back."),it merely
means that he wanted the British empire to continue, for India to be subjugated
under the British rule. Churchill spent
nearly two years in India in the 1890s as an army officer around Bangalore,
hating both India and Indians immensely, just like he hated the denizens of the
other colonies.
After his stint in India, he was involved in the Anglo Boer
wars, where he was imprisoned and his escape from there gave him fame
nationally at just 24. By virtue of that, he was elected to the parliament and
was a cabinet minister at 33. It would take him another thirty odd years to
become the Prime minister.
The war certainly took a toll on him, and inspite of him
leading Britain successfully through it, he lost the 1945 election to the
Labour Party. He however was reelected in 1951 elections to serve another full
term. In his diaries, Sir Francis Alan Brooke, Churchill's chief of the
Imperial General Staff, observed on March 24, 1944, "He seems quite
incapable of concentrating for a few minutes on end, and keeps wandering
continuously."
The book reports that "The inner circle noted Churchill's rapid decline soon after the election. On some days he was nearly his old self, but more often than not he was unable to cope. The private secretary to the queen reported that Churchill often could not follow the trend of a conversation. At one point he even forgot that the electric power industry had been nationalized. He was frequently unable to contain his emotions often irritable and short of temper, at other times breaking into tears or becoming extremely maudlin. He also suffered from delusions of grandiosity, believing that only he could prevent a third world war."
The book reports that "The inner circle noted Churchill's rapid decline soon after the election. On some days he was nearly his old self, but more often than not he was unable to cope. The private secretary to the queen reported that Churchill often could not follow the trend of a conversation. At one point he even forgot that the electric power industry had been nationalized. He was frequently unable to contain his emotions often irritable and short of temper, at other times breaking into tears or becoming extremely maudlin. He also suffered from delusions of grandiosity, believing that only he could prevent a third world war."
Churchill was an imperialist and a white supremacist to the
core, whose ideas on eugenics and the superior and inferior races were barely
different from that of Hitler or Himmler. Superior white man conquering the
primitive, dark-skinned natives, and bringing them the benefits of
“civilisation” was god’s law for him, which he imbibed in Harrow and then
Sandhurst. In
1937, he told the Palestine Royal Commission: "I do not admit for
instance, that a great wrong has been done to the Red Indians of America or the
black people of Australia. I do not admit that a wrong has been done to these
people by the fact that a stronger race, a higher-grade race, a more worldly
wise race to put it that way, has come in and taken their place." “Jolly
little wars against barbarous peoples” delighted him. In Swat valley, among
other areas, he gleefully took part in raids that laid waste to whole valleys,
and in Sudan, he bragged about killing three ‘savages’. Just like Nazis gassed
mentally impaired German citizens regularly in their quest for the perfect
teutonic Aryan race, Churchill’s views on this were similar “I propose that
100,000 degenerate Britons should be forcibly sterilized and others put in
labour camps to halt the decline of the British race. The unnatural and
increasingly rapid growth of the feeble-minded and insane classes, coupled as
it is with steady restriction among all the thrifty, energetic and superior
stocks constitutes a national and race danger which is impossible to
exaggerate. I feel that the source from which the stream of madness is fed
should be cut off and sealed before another year has passed.” The
concentration camps were no different, in this case , made for the Boers during
the Anglo Boer wars, which according to
Churchill, produced ‘minimum suffering’ (28000 deaths). 100000 plus
blacks were in the camps as well.
Every imperial atrocity was defended by him,for putting down
the ‘savages’ who couldn’t submit to the imperial will. “I am strongly in
favour of using poisoned gas against uncivilised tribes...[It] would spread a
lively terror.”How different is this mentality than the Nazi one which used
Zyklon B to murder thousands in death camps? And no, uncivilized
also meant fellow whites of Ireland as well, on whom he unleashed the Black and
Tan thugs as a Colonial Secretary in 1920s.
Churchill was not the only responsible entity for the great
Bengal famine of 1943 (which killed 4 million plus Bengalis in little more than
a year), but his role of being complicit in this catastrophe is certain, where
the root cause was that rice which was either to be planted for next years crop
and was for local consumption was routed to the British troops fighting in west
Asia and north Africa. A scorched earth policy was adopted by Britain in east
of India, to prevent the resources from falling into the hands of the imperial
Japanese army.In response to an urgent request by the Secretary of
State for India, Leo Amery, and Wavell to release food stocks for India,
Churchill responded with a telegram to Wavell asking,” If food is so short,
how is Gandhi not dead yet?” His reaction was that it was their own fault
for “breeding like rabbits” and that the plague was “merrily” culling the
population.
“Skeletal,
half-dead people were streaming into the cities and dying on the streets, but
Churchill – to the astonishment of his staff – had only jeers for them. This
rather undermines the claims that Churchill's imperialism was motivated only by
an altruistic desire to elevate the putatively lower races.”
Barrack Obama, on becoming the US president in 2009 had the
Churchill bust on the presidential desk (which his predecessor George HW Bush
had left) returned to Britain, because
his Kenyan grandfather, Hussein Onyango Obama, was imprisoned without trial for
two years and was tortured on Churchill's watch for anti empire
activities. He was just one of the more
than 150000 Kenyans who underwent
similar treatment. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mau_Mau_Uprising )
One thing we all know is that Britain made it sure while exiting its colonies to engineer
something that will keep them perpetually in the state of disturbance.
Churchill made his stellar contribution in this as well , offering the land in
the British mandate of Palestine to both Jews and Arabs (in his words barbaric
hordes who ate little but camel dung) while harbouring racial hatred for both,
Britain later hastily retreating in May
1948 to leave the two fighting among each other. Or his role in drawing the
country of Iraq, enclosing three warring people to bleed ehttps://rightlog.in/2018/03/hollywood-churchill-india-01/ach other till date.
Of course, holding grudges and being bitter all the time is
not the way forward, otherwise as a Hindu, I should be inundated 24/7 in hatred
against nearly all Turkics and central Asians, Pathans, Portuguese, British ,
Pakistanis, Bangladeshis and whoever has wronged my people. But its equally
important that in today’s world of information being available at our
fingertips, no whitewashing be allowed to be gotten away with, either in the
name of entertainment or political correctness.
